Thursday, December 3, 2009

'Julie & Julia' Writer Assaults More Dead Bodies

Capitalizing on the popularity of the movie "Julie & Julia," writer Julie Powell has released "Cleaving," an account of her affair and her training as a butcher.

When I saw the previews for "Julie & Julia," the film based on Powell's book, in which she spends a year making Julia Child's recipes, I had no desire to see the movie. I didn't know anything about Powell and very little about Child, but I figured the movie wouldn't be animal-friendly.

Child, I later learned, scoffed at vegetarianism.
Personally, I don’t think pure vegetarianism is a healthy lifestyle. It's more fear of food—that whole thing that red meat is bad for you. And then there are people who don't eat meat because it's against their morals. Well, there's nothing you can do with people like that. I've often wondered to myself: Does a vegetarian look forward to dinner, ever?
(For the record, I live for food!)

When I saw the sexist poster for the movie, I knew my decision to skip the film was the right one.

It seems cooking dead animals each day for a year wasn't enough for Powell, though. In "Cleaving: A Story of Marriage, Meat, and Obsession," she recounts an affair that threatened her marriage and her decision to learn the "fascinating trade of cutting up meat."
It's about following the seams between the muscles, separating them in the way they're meant to be separated; about the process of ushering a dead animal into something beautiful and nourishing and sustaining.
Powell claims the work helped to focus her mind.
[It] became obvious that butchery is in the same class to me as knitting, or gardening, or certain skills that you learn, like a purl stitch.
I've never cut raw meat. Even when I was a meat-eater, I found the sight -- much less the touch -- of raw meat disgusting. I've never cooked with it. So I'll just have to trust Powell -- and perhaps numerous serial killers -- that slicing flesh is meditative.

Personally I find chopping vegetables to be relaxing, and no one had to die for me to do that.

I wish Powell would view living animals as beautiful. She acts as if the animal died accidentally and now she's making amends for his death. But their deaths are entirely preventable -- if people would start recognizing whom they are eating and stop spinning meat-eating as something done to honor those "who gave their lives." If people such as Powell would stop romanticizing the cooking of murdered animals.

(Image courtesy of Vegan Underground.)



8 comments:

kilax said...

Interesting post. I have also not seen the movie but read somewhere about the Julie character's book and was disgusted. And if Julia really said that? That's awful.

Vegan Burnout said...

I was annoyed by all the hype over "Julie & Julia" but tried to ignore it. "Cleaving" just grosses me the hell out. I hope the hipster-butcher obsession passes soon, and that it takes the hipster-bacon obsession with it.

Tracy Habenicht said...

Yep, Julia Child really said that. It was published in People in 1999:

http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0,,20128433,00.html

PandorasInk said...

"the way it was meant to be seperated"?? I just can't think of anything productive to say to that. Oy.

Marla said...

I remember that quote for Julia Child. She sucks, her stupid books suck, the stupid movie about her stupid book sucks, etc. I am so with VB: I am sick to death of this hipster obsession with bacon and butchery. The thing that cracks me up is they really think they are rebelling with all this. In fact, they are totally reinforcing the status quo of eating dead animals. And how does her affair factor into any of this? Her poor husband.

tim said...

I have no desire to see the movie. But I have seen reviews and the word is that it totally sucks.

Becci said...

Isn't Julia Child supposed to be this all-knowing, all-powerful chef?

How could she be so lame as to think that a meal must have meat as to be enjoyable? Seriously! You'd have thought she'd have a little more creativity than that. I guess some of us were giving her a bit too much credit.

Tracy Habenicht said...

Becci, you're right. It's like an artist only being able to paint in black and white.